Amateur Vs Professional - 'Do I Wanna Know?'
Structure:
 |
| Arctic Monkeys Structure |
 |
| Student Structure |
The structure of both videos are completely different. For example the students music video of 'Do I Wanna Know' is shown with characters and real life situations with people acting during the video however Arctic Monkeys use animations of situations. This shows the difference in storyline and structure of both videos.
Mise-en-scene
 |
| Artist Props |
 |
| Student Props |
Props - The difference in props is also shown between the student's music video and the artists's music video. For example through acting the characters in the student's music video uses phones, cars and instruments to portray their storyline and to link what they are doing to the song. However through Arctic Monkey's music video the animation characters use props such as wheels and cigarettes with the different female characters representing different types of women. This shows a difference between both videos as the props in the student's video are used to follow the storyline however the artists's music video uses props to create different types of women.
 |
| Student Clothing |
 |
| Artist Clothing |
Clothing - The clothing presented in both music videos are also different. For example the clothing shown in the student's music video is more casual clothing that show general people which allows the audience to follow the storyline of the characters. However in the artist's music video the clothing worn by the females are stereotypical clothing of a 'desirable woman' suggesting the theme of the song as 'crawling back' to a stereotypical woman. However it can be argued that both videos show similarities through clothing as the characters in both videos are wearing clothing to show their individual personalities allowing the audience to follow who they are.
Editing
Through editing both music videos are different.
 |
| Student Editing |
 |
| Artist Edting |
For example at the start of the song there is a simple drum beat that repeats until the main guitar riff comes into the song. Both videos use this beat as part of their music video, however the student music video uses the drum beat to crosscut between two characters introducing the main characters of the storyline in the music video. This is different to the artist's music video that uses the drum beat to show the audience a sound wave of the song relating to their album cover and therefore advertising their album through the music video.
Camerawork/movement
The camera work/movement between both songs is different.
For example the student's music video has a use of close ups mainly as two characters constantly talk to one another having conversations in different settings. The student video also includes close ups of props for example phones and music instruments such as guitar. However camera work/movement in the artist's music video is presented mainly as wide shots and long shots as the animation zooms into different scenes relating to the lyrics of the song. This could have been done to represent different types of women to the audience more effectively.
 |
| Artist Camerawork/Movement |
 |
| Student Camerawork/Movement |
As a result the main difference between Amateur's and Professionals is the production and access between them. For example Arctic Monkeys would generally have better camera work, editing and mise-en-scene than the students for the same song. This is because Arctic Monkeys has more popularity and the opportunity to have better quality cameras and a production team to help with the success of the song and music video.
Natasha Williams
No comments:
Post a Comment